Album Retrospective: Unia

now playing: Sonata Arctica - In the Dark

Sonata Arctica's fifth studio album, Unia ("Dreams"), dropped in May of 2007 and proved immediately divisive among American and Finnish fans alike. The album marked a potentially unsettling change of sound from power metal with progressive influences to what some billed as "pretentious" straight-up progressive metal. Additionally, the cover art debuted a new logo for the band; the previous one had remained unchanged for eight years. This would also be the last album original guitarist Jani Liimatainen would play on: Some complications involving the Finnish military arose, and the band decided to go on without him, taking Elias Viljanen in his place. Understandably, fans had several reasons to be displeased with this album.

I was not one of them. I distinctly remember calling "Good Enough is Good Enough", the closing track, "absolutely perfect". Featuring Tony Kakko on vocals, Henrik Klingenberg on piano, and a string quintet, the minimalistic ballad is a fantastic way to bring the listener down from the sheer sonic power of the rest of the album. The album opens immediately with a strong guitar riff in the vindictive "In Black and White", which would become the standard concert opener for the next two years (and, I would imagine, for some time to come). "Paid in Full", the first single, follows quickly as a ballad with an edge and a strong bass line. Before long, the album swings back into vindication with this album's wolf song, "It Won't Fade": The wolf pack described in the lyrics is a metaphor for the band, and the stray left of the litter is Liimatainen. It seems almost cruel to make him play guitar on this track, but emotion brings out the best playing in everyone, a point clearly made as Kakko switches between clean vocals and screaming over top of angry guitar lines and gentle piano.

As I mentioned in my review of The Days of Grays, "Juliet" is the conclusion of a story. Unia's sixth track, "Caleb", is the beginning, detailing the childhood of the stalker in a progressive, 4/4-to-6/8 crowd-pleaser with a guest choir and a spoken introduction. After that point, the album descends further and further into prog, culminating with "My Dream's But a Drop of Fuel For a Nightmare". The track is six minutes of deliberately nonsensical lyrics and instrumental virtuosity that builds from bass, piano, and vocals to a combination of instruments that can barely be enumerated. Sitting down and listening to the instrumental version of this track (a bonus track limited to the Japanese edition), I was blown away. This is my first response to anyone who claims that Sonata lost their touch with Unia.

However, for as impressive as many of the tracks are, some still don't quite settle well with me. "Under Your Tree", the main ballad of the album, has a melody too similar to "Victoria's Secret" (off Winterheart's Guild, 2003) for my liking and strikes me as downright boring. It's easily my least favorite Sonata song in their entire repertoire. I also feel that, in his effort to write something new, Kakko dropped the ball in "The Harvest", which uses the lyrics "once planted plastic grapes / the harvest of a lifetime / real bad wine" in complete sincerity. It's a shame, as the rest of the song is really quite good -- I've certainly never heard a metal band use a bouzouki before. I just can't get over those lines. Despite all that, Unia certainly isn't a bad album. I think the sensationalist reactions about the stylistic shift and all that were largely unjustified. I would, however, call the album weak. I believe they were trying to make a bold change in their genre and bit off more than they could chew. Fortunately, all the imperfections were ironed out with the release of The Days of Grays, and I (for one) welcome our new power-prog overlords. It goes to show that if you're going to dream, dream big. B